New York society couple Brad and Caroline Sexton (Tim Allen and Kirstie Alley) find themselves targets of an IRS investigation. Running from the law, they discover a safe haven in the Amish community of Intercourse, Pa. Posing as long-lost relatives of local farmer Samuel Yoder (Jay O. Sanders), the Sextons must give up their glamorous ways in order to escape IRS agent Derek Lester (Larry Miller) in director Bryan Spicer's romantic comedy.